, a graduate of the École polytechnique and Inspector General of the Army, takes charge in October 1941 of the (SNS), created on 11 October by merging his Demography Service with the Statistique générale de la France. He has equipped its workshops with hundreds of Bull and Hollerith punch-card machines, able to process millions of individual records in series.
The law of 2 June 1941 forced Jews to register at the prefecture, and the census of professional activities of 17 July 1941 included a question 11: "Does the person belong to the Jewish race?". 's expects these declarations to be processed, and Carmille himself has offered to have his service do it.
Yet Carmille is pursuing another aim. Under cover of checking demobilisation bonuses, his services have built a file of some 2,500,000 demobilised men, invaluable for a future remobilisation against the occupier. An open break with Vichy would expose this tool as much as himself.
Carmille must decide what to do with the declarations: process them to the letter and hand over the expected name files; refuse openly and resign, at the risk of leaving the machinery to a more zealous successor; or take on the processing without giving it any priority, never producing a list of names.
Carmille took on the processing of the declarations of Jews without giving it the slightest priority and without ever handing over a list of names. Nearly 3 years later, the work had produced only an anonymous numerical summary of the Jews registered in June 1941, still unfinished when he was arrested, and the SNS files played no established role in the arrests, deportations and spoliations. Answers to question 11 were, however, used to exempt young men declared Jewish from the . A member of the resistance network, Carmille was secretly preparing a remobilisation from his files. He was arrested in Lyon on 3 February 1944, tortured by 's Gestapo, deported, and died of typhus at on 25 January 1945. His son Robert Carmille and the American journalist have presented these delays as deliberate sabotage based on oral instructions; the report submitted to INSEE in 1998 by , Raymond Lévy-Bruhl and Béatrice Touchelay concluded, on the contrary, that the SNS was not a resistance body and judged those instructions unverifiable. Whether the delay was deliberate remains debated.
T09-034