On 20 October 1941 in Nantes, Lieutenant Colonel Karl Hotz, the German Feldkommandant, is shot dead by 2 Communist militants. German authorities announce the immediate execution of 50 hostages, and of 50 more if the perpetrators are not handed over by midnight on 23 October. The list includes political prisoners and resistance members held for months.
From London, General de Gaulle broadcasts an appeal on 23 October: he acknowledges the courage of French patriots, but expressly asks them to stop killing Germans individually for now. These acts, he argues, trigger reprisals that massacre French civilians without weakening the enemy; the moment for insurrection will come, but only at the coordinated signal. The Communist official receives this message. He also holds instructions from Moscow issued since 22 June: wage armed struggle without delay, to relieve pressure on the Red Army.
He can suspend individual attacks in response to de Gaulle's appeal, pending coordination; continue armed operations as directed by the Communist Party, regardless of the Gaullist call; or propose an internal compromise: press on with sabotage and actions against military targets while avoiding attacks on individuals that trigger civilian reprisals.
The Communist Party leadership maintains its policy of attacks. Between October 1941 and January 1942, the Communist armed groups, soon merged into the Francs-Tireurs et Partisans (FTP), multiply their operations — railway lines, depots, German officers. The day before the appeal, on 22 October, 48 hostages had been shot: 27 at Châteaubriant, including , 17 years old; 16 at Nantes and 5 at Mont-Valérien, near Paris. The tension between Gaullists and Communists over resistance methods persists until 1943. De Gaulle argues that civilian casualties discredit the Resistance in ordinary French eyes; the PCF replies that inaction equals capitulation. The 2 currents converge in the National Council of the Resistance in 1943, but the autumn 1941 disagreement illustrates a deep strategic division.
T09-078