The of May 1939 introduced conscription in peacetime, and everyone senses that, in the event of war, service will become general. For young men moved by pacifist, religious or moral convictions, the call to the colours poses an acute crisis of conscience.
The United Kingdom, instructed by the wrenching divisions of 1914–1918, has provided a legal framework: a conscript can ask to be recognised as a conscientious objector and appear before a local tribunal, which decides to exempt him, to assign him to non-combatant tasks, or to bind him to civilian work of public utility. The tribunal can also reject the application.
The procedure nonetheless exposes one to the suspicion of cowardice and to social opprobrium, and whoever refuses outright to serve faces prison. You are a young conscript, a man of conviction, and you must settle on your course before you are called up.
You can claim the status of objector and face the tribunal, accepting the risk of being judged ill by your peers; refuse all service, at the risk of prison; or accept ordinary service while keeping your scruples to yourself, so as not to set yourself apart. The choice involves your conscience, your reputation and, perhaps, your liberty.
Many will claim the status of objector and appear before the tribunal: over the course of the war, around 61,000 Britons, about 1,000 of them women, will register as conscientious objectors. According to the official figures presented to the Commons in May 1945, the local tribunals pronounce some 3,500 unconditional exemptions (about 6%), nearly 29,000 registrations conditional on civilian work — agriculture, mining, ambulances, civil defence — (nearly half) and about 14,600 placements in non-combatant services, such as the or bomb disposal (about a quarter); about 12,000 applications are finally rejected. Other counts give 18,000 rejections at first hearing, some of them reversed on appeal. The British arrangement, more flexible than that of other countries, makes it possible to reconcile individual conviction and national effort. Refusing outright, for its part, exposed one to prison: some 5,500 objectors would serve time. The handling of objection bears witness to a democracy seeking to respect conscience even in wartime.
T00-036